I wrote the following missive to the Chicago
Tribune; the Trib published it on
Wednesday, 8/12 in slightly redacted form.
Their editing was largely mild and understandable, but they did drop the
last sentence, which I thought was the best line in the letter.
With all the bad news emanating from my alma mater of late, one would think the administrators at what
remains one of the world’s great universities would have more to bewail than an
award that should be far from a source of shame.
Thanks.
As a long ago graduate of the University
of Illinois and a continuing
financial supporter of my alma mater,
I am bothered not a whit by the Princeton Review’s designation of the Big U as
the nation’s Number 1 Party School. The
wailing and gnashing of teeth emanating from the school’s administration in
response to the “award” is not only silly but also demonstrative of the
pusillanimous attitudes that pervade modern day academia.
Who in the world thinks that my alma mater is “…a place where people can just goof off,” as a
university spokesperson lamented after the Princeton Review’s pronouncement? Illinois
and its students consistently rank in the top five universities in the country
by employers. UIUC’s business, agriculture,
and especially its engineering, math, and science programs, are among the best,
if not the best, in the nation. 22 Nobel
Prize winners are, or were, associated with the Big U as either alumni or
faculty members. If you are an Illinois
resident, Champaign is perhaps the
best bargain out there in higher education.
And if you a resident of South Korea
or China , you
know the U of I; much of the technological infrastructure of both countries,
and of others, has been built by U of I alums.
Students at my alma
mater work very hard under intense pressure just to keep up with their
hyper-achieving colleagues. Is it any
wonder that they also play hard when given the opportunity? Do we wish that some of the students would
play hard in less destructive ways?
Certainly. But kids are kids and
temptation is temptation; attempts to keep our kids in cocoons can ultimately
be as destructive as the activities about which the U of I administration is
currently wringing its hands. Part of
going to college is learning how to deal with the stress and temptation that
will be our near constant companions as we proceed through life.
Yes, students at the U of I work very hard and play very
hard. Is the latter so terrible? The world is not run by people who spent
their Saturday nights in college in the library, even so magnificent a library
as those on the Urbana campus.
Mark M. Quinn
No comments:
Post a Comment